Cup linings, compared

PHA vs water-based coatings: what is left behind.

Water-based describes how a cup coating is applied, not what it is. Most aqueous barrier coatings are acrylic or styrene-acrylic plastics in water. What the EU rules say, how a thin plastic coating can sit under a compost certificate, and what to ask.

Updated November 11, 2026 · By Made to Disappear

in short.

  • A water-based (aqueous, dispersion) coating is a polymer suspended in water. The water evaporates on the paper machine; the polymer stays. The question is only ever which polymer.
  • The common chemistries are acrylic latex, styrene-acrylic latex and polyolefin dispersions, according to the companies that make them. Those are conventional synthetic plastics.
  • Under the EU Single-Use Plastics rules, a paper cup with a plastic coating is partly made of plastic and is in scope, whether the coating was extruded or painted on from water. German guidance says there is no general exemption for aqueous dispersions.
  • Compost standards allow small fractions of a product to go untested. A thin synthetic coating can sit inside that allowance under some schemes, so a home compost certificate on the cup does not by itself tell you the coating breaks down.
  • PHA is a polymer that microbes made and microbes eat. A persistent coating polymer in a compost pile does not vanish; it fragments.

what water-based means.

Every paper cup needs a barrier or the coffee soaks through in minutes. For decades the barrier was a thin film of polyethylene pressed onto the board. The newer alternative is a dispersion coating: the barrier polymer is supplied as tiny particles suspended in water, rolled or sprayed onto the paper, and dried. The water goes up the dryer stack. The polymer particles fuse into a continuous film that does the same job the PE film did.

So water-based is a description of the carrier and the application method. It says nothing about the chemistry of the film left behind. Water-based house paint is still acrylic paint once it dries, and the same is true here.

The coating companies are clear about what the films are. Dow's barrier-coating range for cup stock and quick-serve packaging lists acrylic copolymer latex, styrene-acrylic latex and acid-modified polyolefin dispersions. The European coatings trade body describes the category as PE water-based suspensions and acrylic resin-based suspensions. Those are the same polymer families as plastic film, paint and glue.

what the regulators say.

The European Commission's guidelines on the Single-Use Plastics Directive deal with this directly. When a plastic coating or lining is applied to paper or board to protect it against water or grease, the product is a composite that is partly made of plastic and falls inside the Directive. The guidelines list empty paper-based cups with plastic lining or coating as covered, and separately list cups with bio-based plastic linings, and linings marketed as compostable, as covered too. Germany's FAQ on its implementing order answers the question of whether water-based or aqueous dispersions are exempt with: there is no general exception; it depends on the nature of the coating.

The coatings industry disagrees and has asked for aqueous dispersions to be carved out, arguing that a thin acrylic layer is not a structural plastic. That argument may or may not win. What matters for a café owner is that the industry's own statement describes the coatings as acrylic and PE suspensions. Nobody in that debate is claiming the dried film is not a synthetic polymer.

In Canada, the Competition Bureau's 2025 guidelines on environmental claims require a claim such as plastic-free to rest on adequate and proper testing done before the claim is made, and say a claim can be literally true and still create a misleading general impression that fine print does not cure. Since June 2025 private parties can apply to bring such cases themselves.

how a plastic coating can sit under a compost certificate.

This is the part that surprises people. The compost standards test the whole product, but they do not require every constituent to be tested for biodegradation. Under the EN 13432 family, constituents present at less than 1% of the item's mass do not have to demonstrate biodegradation, as long as the total of such untested constituents stays under 5%. The newer ISO and ASTM editions tighten this by requiring constituents between 1% and 10 to 15% to be tested individually.

A barrier coating on a cup is a few grams per square metre on board that weighs a few hundred. It can land under 1%. Whether a certifier lets a non-compostable synthetic coating ride inside that allowance is up to the certifier. TÜV Austria states in its own comparison of the standards that it does not accept any intentional addition of structural polymers deemed unable to biodegrade, at any concentration. Not every scheme says that, and the standards themselves do not.

So a home compost logo on a water-based cup can mean one of two things: the coating polymer was tested and breaks down, or the coating was small enough to be excused from the test. From the outside you cannot tell which. You have to ask.

what is left behind.

Compost microbes break polymers down by cutting the chain and eating the pieces. They have the enzymes for polyesters they have met for millions of years, which is why PHA, starch and cellulose go. Acrylic and styrene-acrylic polymers have carbon-carbon backbones that soil microbes do not cut in any useful timeframe; that durability is the reason they are used in exterior paint. A thin acrylic film in a compost pile does not become soil. The paper around it rots, the film breaks into flakes, and the flakes stay in the finished compost and go onto the garden with it.

That is the microplastic problem in one sentence: the certification can be honest about the cup as a whole while the coating fragment persists, and the marketing word on the sleeve says plastic-free because the film was applied from water.

PHA is also a polymer, and under the EU definition it counts as a plastic because it is made by industrial fermentation rather than found in nature. We do not hide from that. The difference is not the label; it is the ending. PHA is certified to be consumed by the microbes in a garden pile within the home-compost timeframe, with the whole cup tested, not a fraction excused.

PHA liningTypical water-based coating
PolymerPolyhydroxyalkanoate, made by bacteriaAcrylic, styrene-acrylic or polyolefin latex
How it is appliedExtrusion coated or dispersion coatedDispersion coated from water
Plastic under EU rulesYes (industrially fermented polymer)Yes (synthetic polymer coating)
Breaks down in home compostYes, certifiedOnly if the polymer itself was tested and passed; often excused as <1%
What is left after compostingCarbon dioxide, water, biomassPolymer flakes if the film does not biodegrade
Honest labelPHA lined, home compostable, no microplasticsWater-based coating; ask for the polymer

three questions that settle it.

  1. 1

    What polymer is the coating? If the supplier cannot name it, or says water-based or proprietary, treat it as acrylic until shown otherwise.

  2. 2

    Was the coating polymer itself tested for biodegradation, or excused as a minor constituent? Ask for the certificate and the test scope, not the logo.

  3. 3

    Does the certificate cover the finished cup and home composting? A material certificate for the board is not a certificate for the cup.

We answer all three on our certifications page: PHA, 100% certified home-compostable material, certified by TÜV Austria.

questions.

Are water-based coatings plastic-free?

Not in the way the phrase suggests. Water-based describes how the coating is applied. The dried film is a polymer, most often acrylic, styrene-acrylic or polyolefin latex, which are conventional synthetic plastics. Under the EU Single-Use Plastics guidelines a paper cup with such a coating is partly made of plastic.

Can a water-based cup be certified home compostable and still contain plastic?

Yes. Compost standards let constituents under 1% of the product's mass go untested for biodegradation, up to 5% in total. A thin coating can fall under that line. Some certifiers refuse non-compostable polymers at any level; the standards themselves do not. Ask whether the coating polymer was tested.

Do water-based coatings leave microplastics in compost?

If the coating polymer does not biodegrade, the film fragments as the paper rots and the fragments remain in the finished compost. Acrylic and styrene-acrylic polymers are not among the materials that pass compost biodegradation tests on their own.

Is PHA a plastic?

Under the EU definition, yes: polymers made by industrial fermentation are not counted as natural polymers. PHA is also certified to break down completely in home compost conditions, which is the property that matters for a cup. We say PHA lined and home compostable, and we show the certificate.

Is a PE-lined cup worse than a water-based one?

They are often the same polymer family applied differently. Both are plastic films on paper. Neither composts at home unless the polymer has been tested and certified to.

sources.

  1. European Commission, Commission guidelines on single-use plastic products in accordance with Directive (EU) 2019/904, Official Journal C 216, 7 June 2021. eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52021XC0607(03)
  2. EuPIA (European Printing Ink Association), Statement on the applicability of the Single-Use Plastics Directive to functional coatings, November 2025. www.eupia.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/202511_Statement-on-functional-coatings-and-Single-Use-Plastics-Directive_Final.pdf
  3. Dow, Barrier coatings for fibre-based foodservice packaging: product page listing acrylic latex, styrene-acrylic latex and polyolefin dispersion coatings for cup stock. www.dow.com/en-us/market/mkt-pulp-paper/sub-paper-barrier-coating/app-paper-barrier-quick-serve.html
  4. TÜV Austria Belgium, Certification scheme Seedling (based on EN 13432), 2024, section on constituents and additives. be.tuvaustria.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/73/2024/03/CS-Seedling_EN.pdf
  5. TÜV Austria, Comparison of compostability standards (EN 13432, ISO 17088, ASTM D6400, AS 4736, ISO 18606), 2024. okcert.tuvaustria.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/76/2024/12/PD-BA-TABE-CERT-BIO-ID-415_comparison_standards_EN_2407.pdf
  6. TÜV Austria, OK compost HOME certification mark: scope and the standards based on it (AS 5810, NF T 51-800, EN 17427). okcert.tuvaustria.com/ok-compost-home-en/
  7. Competition Bureau Canada, Environmental claims and the Competition Act, enforcement guidelines, June 2025. competition-bureau.canada.ca/en/how-we-foster-competition/education-and-outreach/publications/environmental-claims-and-competition-act
  8. Meereboer, K. W., Misra, M. and Mohanty, A. K., Review of recent advances in the biodegradability of polyhydroxyalkanoate (PHA) bioplastics and their composites, Green Chemistry 22, 5519–5558, 2020. doi.org/10.1039/D0GC01647K

We cite standards, regulators, certifiers, peer-reviewed journals and manufacturers’ own technical pages. If you think we have something wrong, write to hello@madetodisappear.com and we will check it.

Everything we sell is made from 100% certified home-compostable material, certified by TÜV Austria. see the certificates.

keep reading.