Cup linings, compared

PHA vs PLA: what happens to each lining.

PHA and PLA are both called compostable. One breaks down in a backyard pile and the other needs a 58 °C industrial facility. The chemistry, the test data, the microplastics studies and what to ask a supplier.

Updated November 11, 2026 · By Made to Disappear

in short.

  • Both polymers come from fermentation, but PLA is only the first step: the fermented lactic acid is then polymerised in a chemical plant. PHA is the finished polymer when it leaves the microbe.
  • PLA passes the industrial compost standards, which run at 58 ± 2 °C. In a 2018 study across fifteen materials, PLA on its own did not break down under home-composting conditions, while PHB (the most common PHA) broke down in every soil and water condition tested.
  • Two peer-reviewed studies found PLA-lined cups shed more plastic particles into hot drinks than polyethylene-lined cups, not fewer.
  • A PLA cup that does not reach an industrial composter is not composted. A certified home-compostable PHA cup does not depend on a facility.

what the two materials are.

PLA (polylactic acid) starts with plant sugar, usually corn or sugarcane. Microbes ferment the sugar into lactic acid. That acid is then purified, converted to lactide and polymerised with heat, vacuum and a metal catalyst into a stiff, glassy plastic. The fermentation is biological; the polymer is made in a reactor.

PHA (polyhydroxyalkanoate) is a family of polyesters that bacteria build inside their own cells as an energy store, the way we store fat. Fed a carbon source and starved of a nutrient, the cells fill with PHA granules; the polymer is then washed out of the cells. The most common grades are PHB and PHBV. Nothing is polymerised afterwards. What the microbe made is the material on the cup.

That origin is why the two behave differently at the end of life. Microbes that can digest PHA are common in soil, compost and water because PHA is something microbes have always made and eaten. Microbes that attack PLA are scarce, and PLA first has to be broken apart by heat and water before any of them can start.

where each one breaks down.

Every industrial compost standard (EN 13432, ISO 17088, ASTM D6400, AS 4736) uses the same core test: 90% of the carbon in the material must be converted to carbon dioxide by microbes within six months in compost held at 58 ± 2 °C, with the material disintegrated to under 2 mm within twelve weeks. PLA is designed to pass exactly that test. The heat does the first half of the work, splitting the polymer chains by hydrolysis, and microbes finish the fragments.

Take the heat away and PLA stalls. Home-compost certification asks the material to break down at the temperature of a garden pile, not the 58 °C of an industrial facility. TÜV Austria's OK compost HOME mark is the scheme the home-compost standards (AS 5810, NF T 51-800 and EN 17427) were written from.

The clearest independent comparison is a 2018 study in Environmental Science & Technology that put fifteen polymers and blends through controlled composting, home-composting, soil, fresh-water and seawater tests. PLA on its own did not break down under home-composting conditions. PHB was one of only two materials, with thermoplastic starch, that broke down completely in every soil and water condition tested. A 2020 review in Green Chemistry reached the same conclusion across the literature: PHB and PHBV biodegrade in all of the aerobic and anaerobic environments defined by the ASTM standards.

PHA (ours)PLA
Made byBacteria, inside the cell; used as madeFermented lactic acid, then polymerised in a reactor
Industrial compost (58 °C)YesYes
Home compost (garden temperature)Yes, certifiedNo. Did not break down in the 2018 comparison
Soil and waterPHB broke down in every condition testedDid not meet the soil or water standards
What it needsMicrobes, air, moistureSustained heat first, then microbes
If it misses the facilityComposts anywayPersists

microplastics from the cup you drink from.

Compostability is about the end of the cup's life. There is a separate question about the twenty minutes in the middle, when the lining is in contact with a hot drink.

A 2023 study in Chemical Engineering Journal tested eight PLA-lined and polyethylene-lined cups under normal hot-drink conditions. The PLA cups released about 3.6 times as many microplastic particles as the PE cups, roughly 22,000 particles per litre, and 4.2 times as many particles in total once cellulose fibres were counted. A 2026 study in ACS Food Science & Technology found PLA-lined cups released around twelve times the plastic particle mass of PE-lined cups into hot water. Neither paper claims a proven health effect. Both show that swapping PE for PLA does not remove plastic particles from the drink; it tends to add them.

PE itself is not clean: a 2021 Journal of Hazardous Materials study counted roughly 25,000 micron-sized particles released into a single cup of 85 to 90 °C water in fifteen minutes.

PHA does not get a free pass from physics either: any lining can shed. The difference is what a shed particle is. A fragment of PLA or PE in soil or water is a persistent plastic particle. A fragment of PHA is food for the same microbes that compost the cup.

the practical difference for a café.

A PLA cup only composts if three things line up: your city collects food scraps, the facility accepts cups, and the facility runs hot enough for long enough. Miss one and the cup is treated as waste. Many Canadian facilities turn cups away because they cannot tell PLA from PE by eye.

A certified home-compostable PHA cup composts in a backyard bin, a worm farm or a community garden pile, and in an industrial facility too. The customer who takes it home can deal with it. That is the whole reason we chose PHA.

Ask any supplier two questions: what polymer is the lining, and does the certificate say home or industrial? If the answer to the first is PLA, the answer to the second is industrial, whatever the sleeve says.

questions.

Is PLA home compostable?

No. PLA is designed for industrial composting at around 58 °C. In an independent 2018 comparison it did not break down under home-composting conditions. Products certified home compostable use other polymers, such as PHA.

Is PHA better than PLA?

For a cup that may not reach an industrial facility, yes. PHA is certified to break down in a home compost pile and breaks down in soil and water; PLA needs sustained industrial heat. PLA is cheaper and stiffer, which is why it is common.

Do PLA cups release microplastics?

Yes. Peer-reviewed studies in 2023 and 2026 measured more plastic particles released from PLA-lined cups into hot drinks than from polyethylene-lined cups.

Are PHA and PLA both bioplastics?

Both are made from renewable feedstocks and both are polymers, so both are bioplastics in the loose sense. They are different materials with different end-of-life behaviour, and the word bioplastic tells you nothing about where either one composts.

Are Made to Disappear cups PHA or PLA?

PHA. The paper cup is lined with PHA and the lid is PHA. Certified home compostable by TÜV Austria.

sources.

  1. TÜV Austria, Comparison of compostability standards (EN 13432, ISO 17088, ASTM D6400, AS 4736, ISO 18606), 2024. okcert.tuvaustria.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/76/2024/12/PD-BA-TABE-CERT-BIO-ID-415_comparison_standards_EN_2407.pdf
  2. TÜV Austria, OK compost HOME certification mark: scope and the standards based on it (AS 5810, NF T 51-800, EN 17427). okcert.tuvaustria.com/ok-compost-home-en/
  3. Narancic, T. et al., Environmental Science & Technology 52(18), 2018. Fifteen polymers and blends tested in compost, soil, fresh water and seawater. doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.8b02963
  4. Meereboer, K. W., Misra, M. and Mohanty, A. K., Review of recent advances in the biodegradability of polyhydroxyalkanoate (PHA) bioplastics and their composites, Green Chemistry 22, 5519–5558, 2020. doi.org/10.1039/D0GC01647K
  5. Yang, L. et al., Microparticle release from PLA-lined and PE-lined single-use paper cups, Chemical Engineering Journal 468, 143620, 2023. doi.org/10.1016/j.cej.2023.143620
  6. Shi, Y. et al., Plastic particle release from PLA-lined and PE-lined takeaway cups into hot water, ACS Food Science & Technology, 2026. doi.org/10.1021/acsfoodscitech.6c00541
  7. Ranjan, V. P., Joseph, A. and Goel, S., Microplastics and other harmful substances released from disposable paper cups into hot water, Journal of Hazardous Materials 404, 124118, 2021. doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2020.124118

We cite standards, regulators, certifiers, peer-reviewed journals and manufacturers’ own technical pages. If you think we have something wrong, write to hello@madetodisappear.com and we will check it.

Everything we sell is made from 100% certified home-compostable material, certified by TÜV Austria. see the certificates.

keep reading.