Compostability, compared

home compostable vs industrial compostable: not the same claim.

Industrial compostability is tested at 58 °C for six months. Home compostability is tested at garden temperature for twelve. What each standard requires, which certifiers issue which mark, the 1% rule on untested constituents, and why the difference decides whether a cup composts at all.

Updated November 11, 2026 · By Made to Disappear

in short.

  • Industrial: 90% of the carbon converted to carbon dioxide within six months at 58 ± 2 °C, disintegration under 2 mm within twelve weeks, plus heavy-metal and plant-toxicity limits. EN 13432, ISO 17088, ASTM D6400 and AS 4736 all share this core.
  • Home: the same kind of tests at ambient temperature over a longer window. The OK compost HOME scheme came first; AS 5810, NF T 51-800 and EN 17427 were written from it.
  • Industrial-only products should not go in a garden pile. Home-certified products can go in either.

what industrial compostable means.

Every major industrial standard is built on the same four tests. Biodegradation: at least 90% of the material's carbon converted to carbon dioxide by microbes within six months, in compost held at 58 ± 2 °C. Disintegration: after twelve weeks in a pilot composter, no more than 10% of the material's dry weight left on a 2 mm sieve. Chemical limits: heavy metals and fluorine below set thresholds. Plant toxicity: seeds germinate and grow in the resulting compost at least 90% as well as in a control.

The heat is the point. Industrial facilities reach 55 to 65 °C because of the volume of material and the way it is managed. That heat is what allows plastics like PLA to pass: the ester bonds hydrolyse above the polymer's glass transition, then microbes finish the job. A material certified to EN 13432 or ASTM D6400 has shown it can do this in a facility. It has shown nothing about a garden pile.

what home compostable means.

A home pile is smaller, cooler and less controlled. Home-compost certification asks the material to break down at the temperature of a garden pile, not the 58 °C of an industrial facility. TÜV Austria's OK compost HOME mark is the scheme the home-compost standards (AS 5810, NF T 51-800 and EN 17427) were written from. The scheme tests the same properties at ambient temperature with more time allowed: the material has to biodegrade and disintegrate in conditions a domestic pile can actually provide. TÜV Austria describes OK compost HOME as the basis for the home-compost standards rather than a derivative of one.

The practical consequence is simple. A product carrying only an industrial mark should not go into a garden composter; it will still be there next year. A product carrying a home mark can go into a garden composter, a worm bin, a community garden pile or an industrial facility, because a material that breaks down cold also breaks down hot.

Industrial compostableHome compostable
StandardsEN 13432, ISO 17088, ASTM D6400, AS 4736OK compost HOME scheme; AS 5810, NF T 51-800, EN 17427
Test temperature58 ± 2 °CAmbient, garden-pile temperature
Biodegradation90% of carbon to CO2 within 6 months90% within 12 months
DisintegrationUnder 2 mm within 12 weeksLonger window at ambient
Where it compostsIndustrial facility onlyGarden pile, worm bin, community pile, facility
Typical materialsPLA, some blends, coated boardsPHA, starch, cellulose, uncoated paper

the small print both share: untested constituents.

The standards test a product, not every ingredient. Under the EN 13432 family, a constituent present at under 1% of the item's mass need not demonstrate biodegradation, with the untested total capped at 5%; the newer ISO and ASTM editions require components between 1% and 10 to 15% to be tested individually. That allowance exists for inks, pigments and processing aids. It is also wide enough for a thin barrier coating on a cup.

Certifiers can be stricter than the standard. TÜV Austria states that it does not accept any intentional addition of structural polymers that do not biodegrade at any concentration. When you read a compost logo, you are reading the certifier's policy as much as the standard, which is why the certifier's name on the certificate matters.

material certificate versus product certificate.

A second gap: a certificate can cover a raw material (a resin, a board) or a finished item (this cup, this lid). Converting board into a cup adds a seam, an adhesive, print and sometimes a different coating weight. A material certificate does not travel to the cup automatically. Ask whether the certificate names the finished item.

Ours do. Our cups and lids are made from 100% certified home-compostable material, certified by TÜV Austria, and the certificates are listed on the certifications page. How to compost it covers what to do with the cup at home.

questions.

What is the difference between home compostable and industrial compostable?

Industrial compostability is tested at 58 ± 2 °C over six months; home compostability is tested at garden-pile temperature over about twelve months. Industrial-only products need a facility. Home-certified products compost in a backyard pile or a facility.

Can I put industrially compostable cups in my garden compost?

No. They need sustained heat a garden pile does not provide. Only products certified home compostable should go in.

Which standard covers home composting?

The OK compost HOME scheme from TÜV Austria, and the standards based on it: AS 5810 (Australia), NF T 51-800 (France) and EN 17427 (Europe).

Is compostable the same as degradable?

No. Compostable means the material passed a defined test in defined conditions within a set time. Degradable, and similar words, have no fixed test behind them and are often used loosely.

Does a compost logo cover every part of the product?

Not necessarily. Constituents under 1% of the item's mass can go untested under the standards, and a certificate may cover a material rather than the finished product. Read the certificate scope.

sources.

  1. TÜV Austria, Comparison of compostability standards (EN 13432, ISO 17088, ASTM D6400, AS 4736, ISO 18606), 2024. okcert.tuvaustria.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/76/2024/12/PD-BA-TABE-CERT-BIO-ID-415_comparison_standards_EN_2407.pdf
  2. TÜV Austria, OK compost HOME certification mark: scope and the standards based on it (AS 5810, NF T 51-800, EN 17427). okcert.tuvaustria.com/ok-compost-home-en/
  3. TÜV Austria Belgium, Certification scheme Seedling (based on EN 13432), 2024, section on constituents and additives. be.tuvaustria.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/73/2024/03/CS-Seedling_EN.pdf
  4. Narancic, T. et al., Environmental Science & Technology 52(18), 2018. Fifteen polymers and blends tested in compost, soil, fresh water and seawater. doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.8b02963

We cite standards, regulators, certifiers, peer-reviewed journals and manufacturers’ own technical pages. If you think we have something wrong, write to hello@madetodisappear.com and we will check it.

Everything we sell is made from 100% certified home-compostable material, certified by TÜV Austria. see the certificates.

keep reading.